I'm still waffling on what tires to put on the daily. Leaning toward some cheap sumitomos since it's just a daily and they're pretty cheap for the price. If I spend a little more I'd put some Continental DW or hankook v12s maybe. Just cheap normal daily summer tires since I have good winter tires.
Yeah, really depends on what you're after. Honestly, if you don't really drive it too spiritedly around corners, go with a good all season (and believe me, it's weird for me to say that). They last longer, they do better in the rain, they're quieter, and they don't pick up rocks and other debris like summer tires and extreme performance tires do. Long term, that's bad because it equates to rock chips/bare paint. Add in salt during the winter and it's no wonder why clean MkV's are becoming rare.
My GTI is more my fun car now, hence running ZII's. Plus I drive like a dick haha. I love my turns.
Funny enough I'm looking for tires on my car as well. My 06 Rabbit is running on 18" GTI Huff wheels.
The top 3 tires I've been able to narrow it down to:
-Continental ContiExtreme
-Michelin Pilot Sports
-Pirelli P-Zero (Cinturato's have had good reviews too)
Performance aside a quiet tire would be ideal. I've got Yokohamas right now and they're noisy as hell.
The PSS tires are really good. They're actually fairly quiet, wear well, and grip pretty well. The one downside to them is that they have a relatively soft sidewall for a summer tire. But again, if you're just doing normal driving with occasional hard cornering, you'll be okay. Just run the tire pressures a bit higher than what VW specifies. I run about 38-40psi and my door card says to run 35. Now if you're planning to AX, definitely go with an extreme performance tire.
The other thing about tire noise is make sure your alignment is within spec. If the tires are cupped and they've been on your car since day one (i.e. not used tires) and they're cupped, that means a few different things:
1.) Bad alignment
2.) Lack of rotation (I do every 5k)
3.) Tire pressure too high/too low
4.) Worn out shocks/other suspension components
5.) Combination of the above