Stock for Stock as in both Base VW GTI and Ford ST
The GTI is 10x better.
The Ford ST Base package 2 which is roughly 5k more than the base GTI is on level with the base GTI. When I say base, I mean S not LP or PP or SE or Autobahn.
I test drove/rode in Ford ST base package 2, and GTI s before I bought my GTI. GTI was 23.5k. Ford ST was 29k both before tax. For one, GTI fit my price point and it had better features (half power seats, heated seats, 6.5" screen, plaid seats, better overall interior. As for outside looks thats your opinion. Focus had a little more hp stock.
Now thats compairing a Ford Focus ST base package 2, not the base base, so base for base GTI wins easy