Das Silberun Teufel,
Well written extract.
If we agree to disagree; that's fine.
I'm not saying that I don't like the MKIV version.
Just pointing out that that period of time the MKIV had to deal with a higher import tax regime and heavy competition.
In respect to the 200 imported:
They were imported very late towards the end of that model cycle.
The first 50 were sold - with 150 having to be discounted heavily; hurting the original 50 owners who paid full price.
Remember that Holden cut price of their ill fated Adventurer 4WD wagon; only Holden sent the previous purchasers cheques in the mail for @ $3500 once the Ford Territory hit the market.
Mitsubishi made similar blunders with importing the Lancer EVO (not sure which variant). They wanted something like $75-80K, which had many sitting in the showroom as the WRX was 40K and STI 60-65K.
With the MKIV GTI - VW did not have much choice on pricing.
When I first moved to Sydney just over 10 years ago; looked at MKIV Golf std 2.0l - $35K on road. 10 years later same car is same price - again, market dynamics, import taxes, origin of build and company view on market dynamics.
Its no secret that manufacturers like Mitsubishi for instance, make 3 times the profit from their vehicles sold in the Aus market as opposed to home market or North America. Hate to think what profit BMW make as a 330ci is same price as Subaru Liberty GT in South Africa - here its almost twice the price on road.
I think VW was looking to gouge the market with the MKIV R32.
I had read in one of the Euro mags a comparison between the MKIV & MKV R32. MKIV wins out in interior quality; but not much else. Interior of MKV has been considered a sideways step rather than an improvement to most. Still better than new WRX or new EVO.
That's life - every model has to be better than the one it replaces.
As much as I like the Honda Civic Type R and HSV Astra Turbo; I try to keep away from hatches with torsion beam rear ends. Learnt from past experiences.
Flares, scoops, big spoilers are fine if you like the attention - I like the understated Euro BMW - M Power, AMG look instead. Silk velvet over an iron cloak.
I hate what the Holden as done with the SS Commodore to appease the yanks. Same thing was done with the Magna Rallariat sent to North America. IMO stuff like that belongs on race cars, not road cars.
The term underdone refers to lack of performance; esp in the MKIV GTI. This has been rectified with the MKV. Bridging the distance from MKIV R32 performance to MKV R32 not as great - so kudos to you on that point.
Rather than putting together a suspension review - we may well have to do some back to back comparos on MKIV R32 -v- MKV R32.
Next review likely to be up against Ian @ rennenhaus.com.au R32 Koni-sport neuspeed package -v- same car with Koni-FSD; as soon as Jester_Fu gets his dough and act together. Maybe you could tag along, and who knows, you and Jester_Fu may just become friends.
Cheers
WJ