criticism wanted: another HDR attempt

[Moses]

they're old photos some of you may have seen before, but since i no longer have access to a camera with adjustable shutter speed, etc. it's all i've got to work with for HDR editing practice.

the last time i did this they didn't come out so well. i'm hoping i did a little better. i especially like the first one.

please let me know what you think about the PHOTO EDITING and PHOTOGRAPHY. i already know my car is stock ride height with stock wheels.

P.S. if anyone wants to photoshop the telephone lines out of all the photos i'd appreciate it. or out of one of the photos. anything would help.

 

[RSMark5]

1st and last one are actually quite good. :thumbsup:


Much better than your 1st attempt thats for sure. Photomatrix?

 

[Moses]

yeah photomatix and then some very very very very very basic editing with photoshop aftewards.

 

[Ruskiy]

1st picture is sick, if ur car was a little bit lower i would have set it as my default. lol

 

[Mainline]

sucks

 

[guilford32]

sucks

:lol:

 

[Moses]

sucks

elaborate?

 

[Barros VeeDub]

elaborate?

it's hdr

 

[Moses]

yeah whatever it's HDR i didn't say come in here and troll i asked for constructive criticism.

 

[Whiteboy88]

1st picture is sick, if ur car was a little bit lower i would have set it as my default. lol

here you go

it's hdr

people have a very bad idea of hdr. the images are suppose to give you detail in 3 different categorys shadows mids and light

most tend to over do it and make it look like crap i think the first one is very close to what it should be

great example of hdr landscape

 

[Rich241]

1st and 3rd pic are much better then the 2nd. Overall it's slightly to much HDR IMO.

 

[-jakrbt-]

Honestly, I think they look pretty decent. Not too overdone like most HDR shots usually are. The 3rd one seems to be the only "true" HDR, though, as it doesn't have that surreal look to it.

In both the 1st and 3rd pics, though, maybe think about editing out the powerlines.

 

[Whiteboy88]

1st and 3rd pic are much better then the 2nd. Overall it's slightly to much HDR IMO.

the second pic just doesn't have enough lighting on its own to create a good hdr. the 1st i my favorite, maybe at most its slightly over done.

 

[Barros VeeDub]

yeah whatever it's HDR i didn't say come in here and troll i asked for constructive criticism.

im not trolling but im assuming thats what he meant by his comment. there are alot of people who hate hdr whether it looks good or not. im on the fence myself, but i like the first one, but only because of teh scenery

 

[merkeyterkey]

if you squint you cant even tell....