im sure the mileage in the TDI would be great, which is really the only reason id get it, besides the torque, but have you experienced the same thing as Max said re: passing power and it being pretty gutless on the highway? you sound like the right guy to ask going from an R32 to a TDI.. How has that been, having been used to that power and then going to TDI?
3 things about the Passat stood out to me: the engine/power etc., the transmission and the size of the backseat. It is massive. Ive always liked hatchbacks for their utility but visually speaking, from the exterior, they just don't have the same feel of 'class' or whatever as a sedan, especially a black sedan. Most of what keeps me away from just getting an old Crown Victoria or something, besides overall lack of features etc. is the mileage and above all the transmission. Automatics are generally too sloppy for my taste. Ive been living with the wife's Tiguan for a while now, and I like it despite the horrendous mileage it gets for a 4 cyl, but the transmission if left to its own devices constantly bothers me. So I end up fiddling with it more than I would a manual. I usually use Sport to go 1-2-3 gears since the shifts are quick and firm and then I'll throw it in drive since I cant stand the mush feeling of how 'D' operates, not to mention that feeling of neutral esque floating and not true engine braking.. As you DSG guys know, its still a manual so you get the same feeling of true engine braking and the shifts are so fast it just seems so much smoother.
So me not wanting a 2nd slushbox but leaning hard towards an automatic leaves my choices pretty narrow. BMW makes a good 8-speed but Ive come to the realization that those cars are just out of my price range. I could afford to buy a 2010 328i w/50k miles on it. Then I've essentially got a tiny sedan w/very little cargo space, a good inline 6, a satisfactory but mostly lame transmission and epic repair and maintenance costs.. So, sedan w/some cargo space and a DSG makes my options pretty limited. Too bad they stopped making the GLI.
BTW, title of thread has been changed as I think I'm going to make this the longterm different car search thread instead of starting another one. CSB!