Help with with some photo crit/comments

Hey all im entering a photo contest and just wanted some opinons on my possible entries before hand.

Rules:
6 Categories:

# Grand Prize/Best of Show: All entries, regardless of category, will be considered.

# Action/Adventure: Photographs that capture motion, or outdoor sports.

# Black and White: Black and white photography shot in-camera or digitally edited.

# Flora/Fauna: Emphasis on plants and animals in their natural environment.

# Landscape: Broader views of nature that convey a sense of time and place.

# People in the Outdoors: Photographs of people interacting with the outdoors.

# Weather: Photographs of natural phenomena on its own or related to outdoor adventure

There can be digitally edited pics in any of the categories.

1


2


3


4


5


6


7


8


9


10


any comments or faves would be greatly appreciated! The only ones that are edited by the way are 4 and 5. I have an idea of which 6 i want, but i just wanan see what people think of my photography. Thanks for looking

I really like #3, #4, and #8. Really cool pics dude.

thanks!

When I look at #3, I REALLY would want to see a silhouette of a hiker on the tip of that rock. That would just be an incredible image. Do you have the ability to reshoot, or rather can a person even scale that particular rock?

The processing on #4 is pretty cool, very artsy. How does it look w/o the processing?

I like #8! But I would clone out that fly. It's too far away to really notice any details of the fly, and in the overall picture, looks distracting as it's like a black dot.

Just giving my critiques is all :smile:

They look really good, keep it up!

06Rabbit said:

When I look at #3, I REALLY would want to see a silhouette of a hiker on the tip of that rock. That would just be an incredible image. Do you have the ability to reshoot, or rather can a person even scale that particular rock?

The processing on #4 is pretty cool, very artsy. How does it look w/o the processing?

I like #8! But I would clone out that fly. It's too far away to really notice any details of the fly, and in the overall picture, looks distracting as it's like a black dot.

Just giving my critiques is all :smile:

They look really good, keep it up!

Click to expand...

as far as #3- the rock isnt big enough to put a person on top, its not taht large, and i as actuallly pretty close to it.

#8-yea im lookking to clone out the fly cause it is a bit of a mar on the photo and

heere is 4 un-edited:


thansk for the comments!

billybobbovine said:

as far as #3- the rock isnt big enough to put a person on top, its not taht large, and i as actuallly pretty close to it.

Click to expand...

Ahh, I see. Would've just been the cherry on top. Still a great image!

Hope you don't mind, but did some quick processing on that image on how I see fit. Just throwing it out there, as ultimately, it's how you see the image :smile:



(processed / original)

06Rabbit said:

Ahh, I see. Would've just been the cherry on top. Still a great image!

Hope you don't mind, but did some quick processing on that image on how I see fit. Just throwing it out there, as ultimately, it's how you see the image :smile:

(processed / original)

Click to expand...

Thanks! I like the contrastier clouds in the not edited, but lightening the background a bit could ben ice

I'm just jealous you have clouds up there in Oregon. SoCal is just...empty skies...haha!

yea, but sometimes we have too many clouds...especially in the winter

billybobbovine said:

yea, but sometimes we have too many clouds...especially in the winter

Click to expand...

True. Seasons are nonexistent here...good and bad

I like 2 and 5

Moved.

My favorite, and IMO the best one is 3. Nice pics though man :w00t:

# 9